Blind Wine Tasting: How to Host a Night Where Your Only Friend Is Your Palate

Rouge, blanc ou rosé à l'aveugle saurez-vous faire la différence ?

You think you can recognize a wine just by tasting it. Red, white, rosé, light, full-bodied, grape variety X, region Y… You already picture yourself giving advice like a sommelier

.

Spoiler alert: no. Not when you’re hosting a blind wine tasting.

Because in reality, removing the label from a bottle changes everything. Everything you thought you knew collapses. Even your epicurean friend who’s been bragging for ten years about having a flawless palate will end up tasting a white wine and swearing it’s red. That’s the magic of blind tasting: it puts everyone on the same level and reminds you that you’re not just tasting wine. You’re often influenced by everything around a bottle of wine, its price, appellation, grape variety, vintage, estate , information shown on the label or told through the back-label storytelling… in short, everything you’ve already learned to recognize.

Now that you’ve been warned, let’s get serious: here’s how to organize a blind wine tasting at home that gives everyone a real chance to discover wine differently, and in a friendly atmosphere.

1. For a Successful Blind Wine Tasting, Choose Your Wines Strategically

Don’t take every bottle from your cellar. The goal is to surprise, not to end up with five wines that all taste the same. Mix colors, styles, regions, and grape varieties. Choose a light red wine, an aromatic white, a rosé, maybe a sparkling wine, or even something a bit atypical just for fun.

The key is contrast. If all the wines are similar, no one understands anything, and everyone gives up after two or three glasses… of wine, obviously.

A quick movie reference: in Sideways, a simple tasting turns into a playground where everyone thinks they’re right… until reality catches up. That’s exactly the effect you want to create with wine.

2. Hide the Bottles… but Add a Touch of Staging

Rosé wine blind tasting at OTC (On the Cusp)

The easiest option is a thick, opaque paper bag. But if you want to make the tasting memorable, take care with presentation: line up the glasses, pour the wines without showing the bottles, and create a sense of surprise.

You can take inspiration from Babette’s Feast: in this film, guests taste dishes without really knowing what they’re eating, and the entire experience is built around discovery. Wine works the same way. The less information people have, the more they’re forced to express what they feel, aromas (fruity, fresh, oaky, mineral, spicy, etc.) and sensations on the palate (bitterness, acidity, dry, sweet, mellow, astringent, powerful, light, etc.).

Pro tip: avoid bags that are too thin. There’s always someone who tries to cheat by peeking or sniffing the bottle before everyone else… and strangely enough, it’s rarely the most discreet person.

3. Prepare the Right Equipment to Nail the Evening

Clearly define the rules and hide the labels !

You don’t need much, but a few details make all the difference:

Identical glasses for everyone

A notebook and a pen for each guest

Water and bread to “reset” between wines

That moment when everyone starts taking notes is often underestimated. Yet that’s when people realize they don’t really know what to write, and that’s perfectly fine.

In Somm, a 2012 American documentary following candidates for the prestigious Master Sommelier exam, even the best hesitate, doubt, and make mistakes. In other words: no one truly masters it. And that takes the pressure off.

4. Set Simple Rules (Otherwise It Turns into a Useless Debate)

The concept of blind tasting is simple, but it needs a bit of structure:

No discussion until the end: everyone tastes on their own

Everyone writes something down, even if it’s approximate

Wines are revealed only at the very end

That final reveal is what makes the whole evening. The moment when someone realizes they loved the cheapest wine, thought they were drinking a white when it was actually a rosé, or hated the wine they would have chosen without hesitation if they’d seen the label.

And somehow, everyone suddenly becomes a lot more humble.

5. Add a Bit of (Controlled) Chaos

Le vin ça se partage...mais avec modération !

If you want the evening to be truly memorable, you need a bit of surprise.

Add an unexpected wine. Something outside the box: a very fruity wine, a slightly unsettling natural wine, or even a sweet wine slipped between a very tannic red and a highly mineral white.

You can also introduce a mini challenge: guessing the price of the bottle. Most of the time, it’s a complete massacre and that’s exactly what makes it so fun.

Another option: tell a short story about each wine after the reveal. No need for a full oenology lesson. Just enough to add depth. Because in the end, people always remember an anecdote better than a technical data sheet.

6. Keep a Record (You’ll Use It Later and It Makes Great Stories)

At the end, take two minutes to look at the results. Who guessed what ?

Who was completely off ?

That’s often when the best stories are born. The one where someone confused a white wine with a light red. The one where everyone found a very simple wine “amazing.”

If you repeat the experience, you’ll see it: people improve… a little. But above all, they enjoy it much more.

Last but not least

Blind wine tasting is not a performance. It’s not a test to see who knows the most. It’s a very simple way to put things back in perspective and enjoy a great moment with friends.

You remove the labels, the prices, the expectations… and only one question remains: do you like what you’re drinking? And in the end, that’s obviously the only thing that matters.

Ready for your next blind tasting? Ideally with a great bottle (75cl) of On The Cusp rosé wine (On The Cusp literally means Between Two because it’s neither red nor white wine !) or even a magnum to finish the night properly.

Get the vibes, we bring the wine !